The verdict
The Sea to Summit Spark 15 takes the top spot: 850+ fill down, ISO-tested ratings and a sub-2 lb weight at $549.00 — priced like the ultralight it is. The Western Mountaineering MegaLite 30 is the ultralight case at $630.00, and the Feathered Friends Hummingbird UL 30 is the made-to-order case at $579.00. The Kelty Cosmic 20 is the value case, real ISO figures and hydrophobic down at $179.96. The field's gaps are named where they occur: five ranked bags (Bishop Pass 15, MegaLite 30, Hummingbird UL 30, Cat's Meow 20, North Rim 0) are ranked on official routes because their Amazon listings carried no featured offer for the ranked configuration in this pass; the budget rectangular and mummy bags carry maker-stated ratings with no ISO pair, and their cards say so; the Coleman warranty term conflicts between maker records; and satisfaction is the disclosed neutral 12/20 throughout, because no model's own Amazon aggregate could be isolated to the ranked configuration in this pass.
Questions, answered
What does the temperature rating actually mean here?
Every card states its basis. An ISO-tested rating (the successor to EN testing) is a laboratory pair — Comfort, the temperature a standard sleeper stays comfortable, and Limit, the lowest temperature a standard sleeper stays warm curled up. A maker-stated name rating with no ISO pair is the maker's own figure and is not comparable to a tested Comfort figure: in this ranking the Kelty Cosmic 20's name is 20°F but its ISO Comfort is 32°F, and the card prints both. Plan around Comfort, not the name.
Why does every card show the same satisfaction score?
Satisfaction uses only each product's own Amazon aggregate, isolated to the ranked configuration. In this pass no model's aggregate could be isolated to that standard — several makers sell multiple temperatures and lengths through one variation listing — so every ranked product carries the disclosed conservative neutral 12/20, stated in every card intro, rather than a borrowed brand-level or retailer rating.
Down or synthetic — which should I choose?
Down (especially 650-fill and above, hydrophobic-treated) gives the most warmth per ounce and per packed liter, and every backpacking bag in the top half of this ranking is down. Synthetic fill costs less, keeps insulating when damp and dries faster, at roughly double the carried weight for the same warmth — the right trade for wet trips, humid climates and car camping, which is where this ranking's synthetic bags sit.
How much bag do I need for a given night?
Match the bag's ISO Comfort figure — or, for a maker-stated bag, a cautious margin above its name — to the coldest night you actually expect, on an insulated pad: a bag's rating assumes a pad under it, and a cold pad makes any bag sleep cold. Side and restless sleepers should also weigh cut: a trim mummy's tested warmth is worth little if you cannot sleep in it, so the wider-cut bags in this ranking earn their place for sleepers who move.
What should a buyer check about support before choosing?
Read the maker's own record. In this pass no maker's support phone or email was captured to this ranking's standard, so the cards print none rather than guessing — check the maker's own contact page before buying. Warranty terms are quoted from each model's own documents: lifetime-class terms at the top of the field against the Coleman record, whose term conflicts between the maker's own listings and is flagged in the dossier.
Prices are typical US street prices observed during research and change often — check the retailer for the current price. AmRank may earn a commission from links on this page; commissions never change a score. See the affiliate disclosure and methodology.